Class 11.Eng.Core CBSE P-1 A Photograph Hornbill, Question answer Theme Message Characters, explanation

Poem-1

A PHOTOGRAPH by

Shirley Toulson 

Message

The poem Photograph is loss of memory and the transience of life. It explores how people may die but in a strange way they continue to live on in the form of memories. These memories are not just restricted to one's head but can also attain a tangible form such as photographs.

Central Idea of the Poem

Shirley Toulson's poem 'A Photograph' is a loving tribute to her mother. The poem reflects the passage of time and its three stages. In the first stage, the photograph shows his mother enjoying a holiday on a beach along with her two girl cousins. She was 12 at the time.

Irony of The poem

The happiness of poet's mother on seeing the photo and of poet seeing her mother in happy mood is ironic because her mother is sad on the loss of her youth. On the other hand, poet is sad because her mother is no more.

ABOUT THE POEM

SUMMARY

 'A Photograph'is the theme of temporary life.Decay and death are the integral part of human life.With passage of time,a man loses his beauty and youth.Because changing is the rule of nature.A man can not live for a long time? only sweet and sour memories left behind.

The poet looks at the photograph of her mother and her two cousins, Dolly and Betty. The photograph was clicked by the uncle when she was not even born.

Integral -अभिन्न

Decay -बिनाश

Temporary-अस्थाई

Question 1:

What does the word ‘cardboard’ denote in the poem? Why has this word been used?

Answer:

In the poem, the word ‘cardboard’ stands for the frame that supports and holds the photograph. The photograph shows the poet’s mother as a twelve year old girl with two of her cousins, Betty and Dolly.

The word ‘cardboard’ has been used to depict that the photograph is many years old.It shows that life is Transient.

Cardboard-wooden frame/photograph फोटोग्राफ

Denote-संकेत

Preverve- सुरक्षित

Question 2:

What has the camera captured?

Answer:

The camera has captured the three  little girls .One of them is the poetess' mother and her two cousins, Betty and Dolly, Each of them is holding one hand of the mother. The mother was then just a girl of twelve. All the three girls are smiling through their flying hair.They were there in their swimming stresses.They are standing in shallow water.The Photograph shows innocent smiling faces of three girls.

Shallow- छिछला

Question 3:

What has not changed over the years? Does this suggest something to you?

Answer:

The sea has not changed over the years. It is still the same.Its waves are as fresh, shining and tireless

as they were years ago. But there is a great change in those who once paddled in it's beach.The changelessness of sea reminds us of the changes in human face with advancing age.The pretty faces and the feet of the three girls are mortal.

still - अब भी

tireless-निरंतर

 

Question 4:

The poetess’s mother laughed at the snapshot? What did this laugh indicate?

Answer:

This laugh indicated that poet's mother enjoyed  remembering her childhood days.  when she was quite young and free from the tensions and worries of life.The mother was then just a girl of twelve.She laughs at the way they were dressed up for the beach holiday.The pain is that 

lovely days of her childhood will never come back to her.

 

Question 5:

What is the meaning of the line “Both wry with the laboured ease of loss”.

Answer:

The poetess here brings out a similarity between the face of her mother  and her own. Both the faces had turned wry  due to the intense feeling of their great loss. The mother had lost  the joys of her childhood; The poetess had lost the laughter of her mother who was now dead.

The poet is remembering the laughing face of her mother.

Both are now belong to the past. This sense of loss is quite painful to bear the intense

Intense -deep गहरा

 

Question 6:

What does ‘this circumstance’ refer to?

Answer:

This circumstance refers to the death of the poet’s mother.This sad death has left a deep void in the poetess' life. Whenever she saw the photograph of her mother, she become sad as the photograph brings sad nostalgic feeling. She gets lost in the old sweet memories of the past .She finds no one to share her pain and agony with.

Circumstance-परिस्थितियां

Agony-पीडा

Void - व्यर्थ/खालीपन

nostalgic-उदासीन

Question 7:

The three stanzas depict three different phases. Name them.

Answer:

The first phase refers to the time when the poet's mother was just a girl of twelve year, before poet's birth.

 The second phase refers to the  middle age. Where she is laughing at her own snapshot. When the poetess lived with her mother.The mother was then in her thirties or forties. 

The  third phase shows  how sad and lonely poetess feels without her mother. The Mother has been dead for more than twelve years.

Question 8:

How did the three girls face the camera?

Answer:

They removed hair from their faces and stood smiling in the shallow water near the beach. Betty and Dolly stood on either side of the poetess’s mother, holding one of her hands.

Question 9:

What do you think, made the poetess’s mother laugh?

Answer:

The dress and behaviour of her cousins Betty and Dolly made the poetess’s mother laugh. It is evident that they had put on some quaint dress, which amused her.

quaint- अजीब सा ‌‌

Q10. How can you say that the photograph was taken on a windy day?

Ans. In the photograph the girls are seen smiling through their hair, the wind had made their hair fly over their faces. This shows that the photograph was taken on a windy day.

Q11. Explain "The sea holiday was her past,mine is her laughter"

Ans. The mother often remembered the joy of her sea holiday.But it was for her a thing of the past,And for the poetess the laughter of her mother,  was a thing of the past.

Q12. Explain  'Its silence silences'

Ans. The poetess feels the loss of her mother very intensely. Life has no charm left for her.It is like an empty space where there is nothing but silence.

Question 13:

What do you learn about the poetess’s mother from the photograph?

Answer:

The poetess’s mother was a big girl even at the age of twelve. She had a sweet face and enjoyed swimming as well as wading in sea-water with her cousins. Years later she laughed at the clothes they had put on for the sea holiday.

Q1. When did her mother die ?

 Ans.twelve years ago

Q2.How many people were in the photograph?

Ans.three girls

Q3.Who are on both sides of her mother?

Ans. Cousins, Betty and Dolly

Q4.What are the three of them doing in the photograph?

Ans.holding hands and went for paddling

Q5.Who took the photograph of her mother with her cousin?

Ans.Her uncle

Q6.What does 'Terribly Transient Feet' mean in the poem?

Ans.her feet represent the mother, who changed with time while the sea remained the same 

Q7.After how many years did her mother laugh on seeing the photograph?

Ans.twenty-three

Q8What is the meaning of the word 'wry'?

Ans. ironic

Q9.How many phases were depicted in the poem by the poet?

Ans. Three

Q10.What Epithet literary device was used in the poem?

Ans.Terribly transient

 Q11.Explain"Watched their terribly transient feet-

Ans.Human life is transient in nature. At the time of the sea holiday of the poetess mother she was quite young and beautiful but she is no more today only her memories remain.

Annotations

Cardboard- thick paperboard - गत्ता

Paddling-walking with barefeet in shallow water- कम पानी में चलना

Still- motionless -स्थाई

Transient feet- momentary- क्षणिक

Snapshot- photograph- फोटोग्राफ

Wry - disappointment expression- निराश

Poetic Device

1-Silence silences- Alliteration

2- stood still to smile- Alliteration

3- Terribly Transient feet- transferred Epithet/Alliteration

4- Laboured ease- Oxymoron

5-The cardboard shows me-  Personification

 Students  open these link to get released chapters 

https://youtu.be/NBGf4RYZAg4?si=f-DBB0JalDbuM8Si

https://youtu.be/64PAhlRo0Q0?si=4L5Lt7AIO0-Gfujq

https://youtu.be/_a44f1T2Mk8?si=5bWvUFpZIsVgAoJ2

https://youtu.be/cm8KpAGOxMU?si=jpPbfXkoQ3d0uwhq

https://youtu.be/cm8KpAGOxMU?si=jpPbfXkoQ3d0uwhq

Thanks  for watching my video

         English confluence

               By clgautam

if you like my video,plz like, share and subscribe the channel